Good morning ladies and gentlemen,
It’s great to me to standing
in front of you all. My name is Eti Evi Yulita. Today, I am going to tell a
topic to discuss with you. The topic is “organ donor should be stopped”. I
disagree with this statement. Why? Before I tell you my reasons, let me tell
you a story. Last year, before I moved to my new house, I have neighbor. He got
renal failure. He has sold his wealth to cure his disease. But, there is no
change with his condition. Doctor suggests him to do transplantation.
Unfortunately, His renal doesn’t suitable with his family. For your
information, His wife was died and he lives with his old parents. Until now,
doctor still find donors for him. Every three days, he must do dialysis to get
life. Well, His life is just entered and exit from hospital. How if that
condition happen to us? Can you imagine that?
Now, I am going to tell you
my reasons why I stand to disagree if organ donor should be stopped. First,
Organ donor can helpful for who need. Second, Organ donors have procedure to do
it. Third, there is law to regulate about transplantation in our national law
and our religion.
My first reason is organ
donors can helpful who need. I think this is the common reasons why people do
transplantation. Transplantation’s purpose is to substituting broken organ with
new organ which suitable with recipient. Transplantation do because of there is
no other ways to cure the recipient. Transplantation is not simple to do. If there are any other options, I am sure
that they will do the other ways. But if they do not have any other ways,
transplantation is the only way to save them.
For instance, if someone got renal failure and we should be stopped to
do transplantation, their life just for dialysis every day. They life is in
suffering. They life but they do not. By doing transplantation they have change
to life. It can save their life.
My second reason is organ
donors have procedures to do it. Someone will do long medical checkup before
they do transplantation. Doctor will check their healthy history. Doctor will
check their possibility before and after they do transplantation. The most important is organ that will take to
transplantations must be suitable between donors and recipients. It does not do
by general people and without procedures. Organ donors still save if it does by
right procedures according to medical terms. They will not do transplantations
if it doesn’t save for both of recipients and donors. Doctor usually check
recipients ‘family before find other people. In common case, family has biggest
probably suitable with recipients. If they suitable, doctor will check again
what it will be going alright for donors healthy in the future. It is not only about recipients but also
donors’ life. We cannot judge that we should be stopped organ donor if organ
donors do by right procedures. I think this is not justifiable.
My third reasons there is
law to regulate about transplantation in our national law and our religion.
Transplantations are not allowed for commercial reasons (UU No.36
Tahun 2009). Our national law just allow organ donor for human
reasons. Someone who does transplantation for commercial purpose, they will get
punishment if our government knows. You need to know if organ donor selling is
illegal transaction. They done it but government do not know it. I think we
should be stopped the transaction of selling organ not stopped organ donor for
human reasons. This is not suitable reasons to stopped transplantation just
because some people do it for their personal advantages but we forget the real
function of transplantation. Then, there are three types of donors in
transplantation. They are life donors, comma donors, and cadaver donors. In our
religion, cadaver donor is mubah. But it doesn’t mean that life and comma
donors are not allowed. It depends on the situation. For life donors, it is
allowed if it is not vital organ and it will be not disturbing their life. For
comma donors, it is allowed if they have not possible to life again and their
family allowed giving his/her organ to recipients. So, this is not justifiable
if we judge should be stopped organ donor just from one side without look the
real condition.
From all of my reasons, I’ll
summarize it. First, organ donor can help each other if there is no other ways
to cure someone. Second, transplantations still save for both of donors and
recipients because of they do by right
procedures. Third, everyone must know the law about transplantation before says
to stopped transplantation. Transplantation is good to help each other if the
reason is real for human reasons not for commercial reasons. Let’s we be more
wise to see something, not only one side but let’s look to the other side.
